After Philippa Georgiou returned to the Mirror Universe in the third season of Star Trek: Discovery, did her disappearance assist Mirror Kirk’s rise to power?
Did Philippa Georgiou’s removal from the Mirror Universe in Star Trek: Discovery inadvertently assist the parallel model of James T. Kirk’s rise to energy? It is no secret that each Star Trek fan loves a superb mirror episode. In contrast, the idea of evil doppelgangers performs neatly into Star Trek‘s philosophical leanings. The Mirror Universe has endured a much better check of time than Sulu’s shirtless fencing or the informal 1960s sexism. It stays a key setting even within the fashionable period with Star Trek: Discovery.
The Discovery crew had been dragged into Lorca’s scheme, and. In contrast, Jason Isaacs’ villain was ultimately defeated. Emperor Georgiou has introduced again into the Prime Universe as a memento, compelled to construct a wholly new life in an additional peaceable environment. Georgiou quickly returned to the Mirror Universe in Star Trek: Discovery season 3, when the space between her physique and her house world started to tear the previous Emperor aside.
This newest journey between universes drew various parallels between Georgiou and Kirk, most of which had been purely thematic, corresponding to attempting to mix into the violent environment without compromising morality or arousing suspicion. Nonetheless, Star Trek: Discovery season Three additionally revealed an extra tangible frequent thread between Michelle Yeoh’s Georgiou and William Shatner’s Kirk – and it is not their most popular temperature for Kelpien steak.
The Tantalus Subject In “Mirror, Mirror”
In the original show, the ISS Enterprise is provided with varied devices and options that may be discovered on the ship’s Prime Universe counterpart. The uniforms include golden sashes. There are agonizer cubicles for the needs of torture. Inside Captain Kirk’s quarters is a lethal piece of kit referred to as a Tantalus Subject. Hidden behind a secret panel, the Tantalus area permits Kirk to spy on his enemies and kill them with the push of a button, and this plays a serious position in Terran Kirk’s rise to energy. “Mirror, Mirror” reveals that Kirk really killed his predecessor, Christopher Pike, to grab management of the Enterprise. Still, it surely’s the Tantalus area that has allowed him to become a real pressure inside the Empire.
Mirror Kirk’s feminine companion (quickly to be Prime Kirk’s too, naturally) sheds some gentle on the place this all-powerful weapon got here from; however, it solely refers to an unknown scientist on an unspecified planet. In the future, throughout his reign, Kirk attacked and plundered a science lab, occurred upon the Tantalus area by probability, and utilized the weapon in secret ever since. As for the scientist in the query, audiobooks and novels provide differing accounts of who Kirk stole from; however, their definitive identification stays ambiguous. On the finish of “Mirror, Mirror,” Prime Kirk informs Mirror Spock about the Tantalus area, and the Vulcan makes use of the machine to overtake the Empire for the higher.
Mirror Georgiou Additionally Has A Tantalus Subject
The structure and distinctive pear-shaped buttons are unmistakable, and make sure that Emperor Georgiou possesses the identical kind of all-seeing weapon as Kirk in “Mirror, Mirror.” Captain Killy additionally feedback that Georgiou might end Burnham on the contact of a button if she wished, alluding to the identical Tantalus area energy that Mirror Kirk will at some point maintain. However, what occurs to Georgiou’s gadget after her departure?
When the Discovery crew journey to the Mirror Universe, they transfer by dimensions, however not by time, which means the parallel world occasions of Star Trek: Discovery season 1 happen roughly a decade previous to the “Mirror, Mirror” transporter accident on the Enterprise – lengthy earlier than Kirk’s Terran heyday. In Star Trek: Discovery‘s inaugural season, the ISS Discovery swaps locations with Prime Discovery and is destroyed by Klingons, who understandably assume the ship belongs to the Federation. Nonetheless, the ISS Discovery’s particles are left floating by area, and there is sufficient left for Starfleet to imagine the unique Discovery has been destroyed. For the reason that Prime and Mirror Discovery ships swapped locations on the primary journey, it is potential they do the identical for the return journey, and when the united states discovery springs again to the Prime Universe in “What’s Previous Is Prologue,” the particles of its Mirror counterpart would possibly return house additionally. This could imply Georgiou’s Tantalus area and some other surviving Terran devices had been dumped again into the Mirror Universe simply ready to be picked up.
“Terra Firma Pt. 2” is about even additional within the timeline due to the Guardian Endlessly allowing Georgiou to alter the historical past. Whether or not these occasions change Star Trek: Discovery season 1’s Mirror arc, create a brand new timeline, or do not actually occur in any respect is left considerably ambiguous; however, in both cases, the Tantalus area is left unattended within the Mirror Universe.
Does Kirk Discover Georgiou’s Tantalus Subject?
Whereas it is less complicated to imagine that Kirk and Georgiou possess two separate Tantalus fields, these units should be extremely uncommon, perhaps even one-of-a-kind. If the weapon may very well be purchased on the Terran black market, the complete Empire probably would’ve Tantalus-ed themselves into extinction way back. Moreover, Spock would not have been in a position to make use of the Tantalus area in opposition to the Empire so successfully if there was a couple of in existence. Some would argue that because the two machines do not look precisely identical (60 years of manufacturing worth enhancements for you), they should be completely different fashions. However, once more, Ethan Peck does not look precisely like Leonard Nimoy, so they’re each Spock.
Because the Emperor, Georgiou possessing an all-powerful loss of life machine, is sensible. They do not seem to maintain her Tantalus Subject a complete secret since Tilly and Saru each know the reality. Maybe, then, it may be assumed that solely the Emperor ought to have entry to such a devastating weapon rightly. This could clarify why Kirk is much extra coy about his machine. But when the Tantalus Subject is so uncommon and usually wielded by the Emperor reasonably than mere captains, how did Kirk get his arms on one? Assuming the ISS Discovery’s wreckage was returned to the Mirror Universe when the Prime Discovery returned, it is sensible that the scraps could be plucked from the area by a random scientist and brought again to his lab for experimentation. Mirror Kirk would possibly be picked up this uncommon temporal anomaly, which is why he ransacked that particular lab – searching for one thing otherworldly and discovering Emperor Georgiou’s misplaced Tantalus area.
Though there’s nothing concrete to attach Kirk and Georgiou’s Tantalus fields properly now in Star Trek: Discovery season 3, the connection would add an enchanting piece of backstory if true. Had the Discovery’s Terran journey not occurred and Georgiou hadn’t switched universes, Mirror Kirk would possibly by no means have to turn out to be formidable determine he was in Star Trek: The Original Series.