Film critics have long debated the merits of review aggregators like Rotten Tomatoes, which simplifies the complex art of film criticism into a binary score. Proponents of Rotten Tomatoes argue that it democratizes the art of criticism, but critics contend that such metrics are largely useless for nuanced opinions. This is because aggregators like Rotten Tomatoes work on a binary scale, reducing the complexity of a film to a simplistic “rotten” or “fresh” label. While Rotten Tomatoes can shed a spotlight on overlooked films like Leave No Trace, which garnered a 100% approval rating, it is but one part of the critical conversation.
Leave No Trace, a 2018 drama directed by Debra Granik, is a thought-provoking exploration of assimilation and freedom of choice. The film tells the story of Will, a former military veteran who lives “off the grid” with his teenage daughter, Tom. When they are discovered, they must navigate the challenges of assimilating into mainstream society. Granik’s nuanced approach to the topic avoids judgment, instead opting for a nuanced exploration of the complexities of nomadic living.
A Still From Leave No Trace by Debra Granik (Via IMDB)
Granik’s direction is notable for its unflinching portrayal of the challenges faced by Will and Tom. The film explores the intricate dance between Will’s trauma from combat and his reluctance to seek help. His unwillingness to ask for assistance stems from a desire to maintain a sense of authority and safety for his daughter. The film’s portrayal of Will’s struggles is refreshingly free from toxic masculinity tropes.
Through Will and Tom’s experiences, the film illustrates the difficulties of assimilation. Rather than demonizing either party, Granik’s direction humanizes the characters and their struggles. The film’s unsentimental approach to the challenges faced by both Will and Tom adds to its authenticity.
In one of the film’s most poignant moments, Will must confront the reality of leaving his daughter behind, allowing her to make her own choices. This turning point is handled with sensitivity and nuance, avoiding manipulation or sentimentality. Leave No Trace is a masterclass in subtlety, boasting a restrained style that makes its characters’ experiences feel authentic and relatable.
As a film, Leave No Trace is worthy of critical rediscovery. Its unflashy style may not have generated the same level of buzz as some of its more flashy peers, but its realistic portrayal of the human experience makes it a timeless tale that is worthy of analysis.
