The concept of reincarnation has been a compelling idea in film, with three adaptations of the play “Heaven Can Wait” making it to the big screen. The most recent remake, Down to Earth, starring Chris Rock and directed by the Weitz brothers, takes a unique approach to the theme. The film follows Lance Barton, a struggling comedian who dies prematurely and is given a second chance by an angel from heaven. Lance is reincarnated into the body of a wealthy, older white man, Charles Wellington III, and must adjust to his new life while pursuing his dreams.
Chris Rock, at the height of his fame, brought his observational humor and stage persona to the film, which follows a familiar narrative arc of an individual trying to redeem themselves. The movie is heartwarming, with Rock’s brand of humor bringing some laughs, but it struggles to evoke emotional gravitas and lacks depth. The film’s creative shortcomings are made up for by its stacked cast, including Regina King, Eugene Levy, Jennifer Coolidge, and Mark Addy.
Chris Rock (Image via Getty)
Compared to Warren Beatty’s 1978 film “Heaven Can Wait,” Down to Earth falls short. Beatty’s film balances classic Hollywood sentimentality with New Hollywood sardonic wit, making it a more charming and insightful comedy. Rock’s performance is uneven, struggling to hold the screen patiently, whereas Beatty’s performance is more nuanced and thoughtful. Despite its shortcomings, Down to Earth is a pleasant viewing experience, with sporadic laughs and an unexpected heart.
The film’s concept, while unoriginal, has been rehashed and reworked to fit modern sensibilities. With the wealth of comedic talent on screen, including Rock’s own brand of humor, Down to Earth is a film that will appeal to fans of the comedian. However, it fails to live up to the standards set by Beatty’s endearing fantasy comedy.
