Deciding on whether to go for a Mac or a Windows PC is quite a big one for anyone working in the creative field. You’re likely to spend many hours daily on whichever machine you choose, possibly over several years. Also, considering the high cost of quality laptops and desktop computers, replacing one if it doesn’t meet your expectations isn’t always easy.
Each system comes with its own advantages and drawbacks. There’s no single right option for everyone, so your personal needs, budget, and how you plan to use the device should guide your final pick.
This post outlines the strengths and weaknesses of both Mac and Windows devices across different areas to assist you in selecting the one that matches your creative demands.
MacBooks bring sleek design and unified performance to the creative table (Photo: Microsoft/Apple)
Mac vs Windows: System Ideology and Production Approach
One key difference you’ll notice early on is that Apple alone produces Mac computers, while Windows PCs come from multiple companies, including Dell, HP, Lenovo, and even Microsoft itself. This unique approach by Apple gives Mac systems a level of consistency that is hard to match.
Macs are often praised for their efficient performance and stability. Since Apple controls both the hardware and software, the systems are designed to work smoothly together. Everything is properly tuned to function without much hassle from the first time you turn it on.
Apple’s use of its M1, M2, and M3 chips has made these devices even more efficient. That’s why the MacBook Pro M3 Max is often referred to as a top choice for creatives. Thunderbolt ports included in Macs also enable fast connections to other devices, which is important for creative tasks such as video editing and music production.
Newer versions of the MacBook Pro, possibly powered by M4 chips, are expected to offer even more improvement when they arrive. However, Apple’s tight control also means fewer choices. You’re limited to the models Apple offers and have to stay within its system of apps and accessories. The pricing is also on the high side, and it’s not always easy to install non-Apple software.
Windows computers, by contrast, give users more freedom. From budget-friendly laptops to high-end desktops, there are many brands and configurations to consider. Most Windows PCs are also easier to upgrade and adjust, giving more room for those who prefer custom setups. High-spec Windows machines often come with powerful graphics cards, suitable for game development, 3D rendering or heavy-duty video editing.
Macs are a good fit if your focus is on reliable performance and you want something that works straight away without extra work. But if you like having more control over how your computer is built or need very specific features for your work, a Windows PC might be a better option.
Mac vs Windows: Software Availability and Compatibility
Another major consideration is whether your preferred software works on Mac or Windows. Some popular creative tools are only available for one of the platforms. For instance, Sketch and Final Cut Pro work only on Macs, while many advanced CAD programs run better or only fully on Windows.
That’s why most laptops recommended for AutoCAD and similar tasks tend to be Windows models. One of the top choices here is the ASUS ProArt P16.
Still, most top creative software like Adobe Photoshop, Illustrator, and Premiere Pro work well on both systems. Alternatives such as Affinity Photo and Affinity Designer are also available on both platforms.
A growing number of creative tools, including Canva, Figma, and Adobe Express, now run through web browsers. This means they work just fine whether you’re on a Mac or a Windows device.
If there’s software that’s central to your work and it’s exclusive to either Mac or Windows, that should guide your decision. But for most people, Windows tends to offer more options and a wider range of programs to choose from.
Mac vs Windows: User Interface and Experience
Since you’ll spend a large part of your time navigating your computer’s interface, it’s wise to think about how each one functions. Windows and macOS approach this quite differently.
Mac systems are known for their clean, organised interface. They focus on keeping things simple and consistent across the system. This helps users stay focused, especially when working on creative tasks. Shortcuts and gesture controls are designed to make the workflow more efficient once you get used to them.
Windows, on the other hand, offers more flexibility. You can adjust the layout and settings to suit your style of work. Whether that’s an advantage or not depends on how much you enjoy customisation.
For some, the touchscreen support found in many Windows laptops is a major benefit. Devices like the Dell Latitude 9410 or the dual-screen ASUS Zenbook Duo OLED offer experiences you won’t find in a Mac. Apple has yet to introduce a touchscreen laptop. The closest is using an iPad with a keyboard, which runs a different operating system entirely and lacks full desktop features.
Windows also powers a range of machines that can switch between tablet and laptop use. These hybrids are useful for flexibility, like watching videos in tent mode or taking notes on the go. Apple does not have any devices in this category.
If you don’t care much about touchscreen features or hybrid options, the choice becomes about whether you prefer something steady and fixed like macOS or something adjustable like Windows.
Mac vs Windows: Display Quality and Visual Performance
For people who do design, photography, video, or 3D work, the display quality of their machine plays a big role in the work outcome. MacBooks have gained a strong reputation for their high-resolution Retina displays.
Windows gives users more freedom to customize their creative setup (Photo: Shutterstock)
They provide accurate colour reproduction and support wide colour ranges like the P3 gamut. This kind of quality makes Macs a common pick in graphic design studios, photo agencies, and publishing houses.
Windows computers, due to the range of manufacturers involved, offer far more display choices. There are many options that come with 4K or even 8K displays. This allows users to choose based on what fits their specific task and their budget.
Even if you buy a MacBook, you’re not limited to Apple-made monitors. You can connect external displays of any brand and enjoy similar benefits. So when it comes to display options, there’s enough flexibility on both sides to meet creative needs.
Mac vs Windows: Device Integration and Connectivity
The way devices link up with each other today matters more than ever. If you already use Apple products like an iPhone, iPad, or Apple Watch, using a Mac adds to the convenience. With features like Handoff, AirDrop, and Universal Clipboard, it’s easier to transfer work or keep files synced across all your devices.
Windows systems don’t offer the same kind of tight link between products, but they do work well with Android phones and Microsoft’s services. Windows’ OneDrive handles file syncing and sharing, while the Your Phone app bridges the gap between your Android device and your PC.
So if most of your other gadgets are Apple-made, a Mac will make your work process smoother. If your phone and other tools are from different makers or you use Android heavily, Windows will be the more practical option.
Mac vs Windows: Protection and Device Security
Protecting your creative work and private files is very important, especially if they belong to clients or you plan to sell them. Macs are often seen as less prone to attacks and viruses. This is largely because Apple maintains strict control over its system, and there are fewer viruses written for macOS.
However, Windows has taken great steps forward in recent times. Security updates come regularly, and the built-in Windows Defender offers strong protection straight out of the box.
Whether you go with a Mac or a Windows system, keeping your device secure means staying up to date with updates and using trusted software. With both options now offering solid protection, you can focus more on choosing the one that best suits your creative setup.
